The best inheritance lawyers

The right inheritance lawyer for you is a New York attorney who regularly appears in the Surrogate's Court of the county where the estate is being handled, who can explain your rights in plain language at the first meeting, and who tells you in writing how the fee works. Rankings and advertising slogans say little about any of those things.

Most people start looking for help at an awkward moment. A parent has died, a sibling is acting as executor, and months later nothing has been paid out. Or a letter arrives from a court in a county the person barely knows. This page covers what an inheritance lawyer actually does and how to judge one.

Whose Lawyer Is the Estate's Lawyer?

This is the first thing to understand. The attorney handling probate represents the executor or administrator, not the beneficiaries. That lawyer may be pleasant and helpful, but if your interests and the executor's interests split, for example over the sale price of a house or a large expense charged to the estate, the estate's lawyer cannot advise you. A beneficiary who wants advice about their own share needs their own counsel.

What Beneficiaries and Heirs Are Entitled To

New York gives people who inherit real, enforceable rights:

  • Notice. Relatives who would inherit without a will must be notified when a will is offered for probate.
  • Information. Beneficiaries can ask the executor about assets, debts and timing, and can ask the court to require a formal accounting.
  • A share set by law if there is no will. Under EPTL 4-1.1, a spouse and children share the estate: the spouse receives the first $50,000 plus half of the rest, and the children divide the remainder. With a spouse and no children, the spouse takes everything.
  • A spouse's protected share. A surviving spouse who is left less can generally elect to take the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the net estate, under EPTL 5-1.1-A.

New York has no inheritance tax. If estate tax is owed, the estate pays it before distribution, not the heir from their own pocket.

When It Makes Sense to Hire Your Own Lawyer

  • The executor has stopped answering questions, or months pass with no explanation.
  • You believe the will was signed under pressure or when the person could no longer understand it.
  • Property is being sold to a relative, or at a price that seems low.
  • You were left out of a will that earlier versions included you in.
  • You are the spouse and the will leaves you less than the law guarantees.
  • The estate includes a house that some heirs want to keep and others want sold.

Some of these situations have deadlines that run from the date papers are served or letters are issued. Waiting until you are sure there is a problem can cost options.

Questions Worth Asking at the First Meeting

  1. "How often do you appear in the Surrogate's Court for this county?"
  2. "Who will actually work on the matter day to day?"
  3. "How is the fee calculated, and will I get that in writing?"
  4. "What is the realistic range of outcomes, including doing nothing?"
  5. "What will you need from me in the next two weeks?"

A lawyer who promises a specific result at the first meeting, before seeing the will and the estate's papers, is telling you something about how they work.

An Example

Three siblings inherit a two-family house in the Bronx under their mother's will. The brother named as executor lives upstairs and has not listed the house for sale. The sisters want their shares. Each sister's lawyer can ask the executor for a timeline, request an accounting, and, if needed, petition the court to compel action or to address the brother's use of the property. Often a written plan, agreed early, avoids the petition entirely.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a lawyer to receive an inheritance?

Not always. If the executor is communicating and the will is clear, many beneficiaries simply sign a release and receive their share. Advice is worth having before you sign that release.

Who pays for a beneficiary's lawyer?

Usually the beneficiary. Legal fees of the executor's attorney are paid from the estate, subject to court review.

Is there an inheritance tax in New York?

No. New York has an estate tax on large estates, paid by the estate, but no tax on the person who inherits.

What if there is no will?

The estate passes under the intestacy statute, starting with the spouse and children, and the court appoints an administrator.

Read more on our estate litigation and probate pages.

Questions about a specific situation? Call Morgan Legal Group at (888) 529-1315.