Living Wills in New York: What They Do and Don't Do

A living will is a written statement of the medical treatment a person would or would not want if they could no longer speak for themselves, usually at the end of life. It is not a will about property. In New York it works best alongside a health care proxy: the proxy names the person who decides, and the living will tells that person, and the doctors, what the patient wanted.

Is a Living Will Legally Binding in New York?

New York has no statute that creates an official living will form, unlike the health care proxy, which has its own law in Public Health Law Article 29-C. That surprises people. It does not make a living will useless. New York courts have long treated a clear written statement of a person's treatment wishes as strong evidence of what that person wants, and the law directs the people who decide for an incapacitated patient to follow the patient's wishes. A health care agent must decide according to the patient's wishes, including religious and moral beliefs, when those wishes are reasonably known (Public Health Law § 2982). A family surrogate chosen under the Family Health Care Decisions Act is held to the same standard (Public Health Law § 2994-d). A living will is often the best proof of what those wishes were.

Why the Feeding Tube Question Matters

One detail in New York law makes a written record especially important. A health care agent may not decide about artificial nutrition and hydration, such as a feeding tube or IV fluids, unless the patient's wishes on that subject are reasonably known. A sentence in a living will such as "I do not want artificial nutrition or hydration if I am permanently unconscious" can settle a question that otherwise divides families at the bedside.

What a New York Living Will Usually Covers

  • Whether to use life-sustaining treatment if the person is terminally ill, permanently unconscious, or has an irreversible condition with no reasonable hope of recovery.
  • Resuscitation, mechanical ventilation and dialysis.
  • Artificial nutrition and hydration.
  • Pain relief, including a preference for comfort even if it may shorten life.
  • Religious or personal values the decision-makers should consider.
  • Organ donation wishes, or a reference to the separate donor registry.

A living will does not need to be long. A page of clear, specific statements is more useful than five pages of general language.

Living Will, Health Care Proxy and MOLST: How They Differ

  • Health care proxy. Names an agent to make all medical decisions when the person cannot. It must be signed in front of two adult witnesses, and the agent cannot be one of them.
  • Living will. States the person's wishes. It guides the agent and the doctors but does not name a decision-maker.
  • MOLST. A medical order completed with a physician for a seriously ill patient. It travels with the patient and tells emergency and hospital staff what to do now. It complements, but does not replace, the other two.

A Common Situation

Consider a woman in Queens whose mother has advanced dementia and is admitted to the hospital with pneumonia. The mother signed a health care proxy years ago naming her daughter, but never wrote down her wishes. The daughter believes her mother would refuse a feeding tube; her brother disagrees. Without written evidence of the mother's wishes on that point, the agent's authority over artificial nutrition is limited, and the family may face a much harder process. A short living will, signed at the same time as the proxy, would likely have answered the question.

Signing and Keeping It

Because there is no statutory form, the safest practice is to sign the living will with the same formality as a health care proxy, in front of two adult witnesses who are not named as agents, and many people also have it notarized. Then:

  • give copies to the health care agent, the alternate agent and the primary doctor;
  • ask that it be scanned into the hospital's records at the next admission;
  • review it after a serious diagnosis, a move, or a change in beliefs.

Short Answers

Where can I get a living will form in New York?

There is no single official form for a living will in New York. Hospitals and legal aid organizations often provide sample language, and an attorney can prepare one that matches the health care proxy.

Do I need a lawyer for a living will?

No, but it is usually prepared together with the health care proxy, power of attorney and will so the documents are consistent.

Can a living will be changed?

Yes, at any time while the person has capacity. Destroy old copies and give the new one to everyone who had the old one.

See our elder law and estate planning pages.

Questions about a specific situation? Call Morgan Legal Group at (888) 529-1315.