Probate Real Estate

Buying a house in probate in New York is very possible, but the seller is not a person; it is an estate, acting through an executor or administrator the Surrogate's Court has appointed. Most of the risk for a buyer comes from one question: does the person signing the contract actually have authority to sell? Settle that early and the rest looks much like an ordinary purchase.

Who Can Sell

Only the fiduciary holding letters from the court can sign a deed for a house that was in the deceased owner's sole name. A son or daughter who "is handling things" but has no letters cannot give you good title, however sincere. Ask the listing agent, early, for a copy of the letters testamentary or letters of administration.

Many wills give the executor a power of sale, which lets the executor sell without asking the court. An administrator, or an executor without that power, generally needs the court's permission; SCPA 1902 lists the purposes for which the court may allow a sale. Your title company will want to see which situation applies.

What Is Different About These Deals

  • As-is condition. The executor never lived in the house and usually will not make repairs or give detailed disclosures. Budget for a thorough inspection.
  • Heirs in the background. Beneficiaries may disagree about price. When an heir objects later, the objection is usually aimed at the executor's conduct in the estate accounting rather than at the buyer, especially where the executor had authority and the sale was at arm's length. Your attorney and title company will still want the authority documented.
  • Occupants. A relative may still live in the house. The contract should say the property will be delivered vacant, and closing should not happen until it is.
  • Timing. If letters have not issued yet, nobody can close. A signed contract can wait for them, but your mortgage commitment and rate lock may not.

Protections Worth Building Into the Contract

  1. A copy of current letters, or a condition that closing occurs only after they issue.
  2. If court approval is required, a contingency for that approval with a firm outside date.
  3. Vacant delivery, with a walk-through right before closing.
  4. A clear statement of what personal property stays, since estates sometimes leave furniture behind.
  5. Your down payment held in escrow by the seller's attorney, as is standard in New York.

How Long It Takes

A sale by an executor with letters and a power of sale moves at roughly the pace of any New York closing. A sale that needs a court order, or that waits for letters to issue, takes longer and is harder to predict. Ask at the start which of those you are dealing with.

An Example

Consider a buyer in Bayside who signs a contract on a ranch house. The seller's brochure lists "estate of" as owner, and the buyer's attorney asks for the letters. They turn out to be letters of administration, with a limitation that the administrator may not sell real property without further order. The contract is amended to add a court-approval contingency. The closing happens later than planned, but on clean title.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I buy a house that is in probate?

Make an offer through the listing agent, have your attorney confirm the fiduciary's letters and authority, and sign a contract with the protections above.

Can I buy a probate house for less than market value?

Sometimes, because the estate wants a quick, as-is sale. But the executor has a duty to the beneficiaries to get a fair price, so expect a negotiation, not a giveaway.

Does all real estate go through probate?

No. A house owned jointly with a right of survivorship, held in a trust, or transferred by a recorded transfer-on-death deed passes outside the court.

Who pays the estate's closing costs?

The estate pays its own seller costs from the sale proceeds, which go into the estate account, not directly to the heirs.

For the seller's side, see our probate and real estate pages.

Questions about a specific situation? Call Morgan Legal Group at (888) 529-1315.